Newly designed solid coupling medium for reducing trapped air pockets during extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy_ a phantom study.
BMC urology · 2021 · Vol. 21 · Issue 1 · 79
Academy Summary
Wang and colleagues evaluated a newly designed solid coupling medium, termed an isolation-coupling pad or icPad, intended to reduce trapped air between the lithotripter treatment head and the coupling surface during shock wave lithotripsy.
The study addressed a recognised limitation of conventional semi-liquid coupling gel.
Even when gel is applied carefully, small air pockets may remain between:
- Lithotripter treatment head
- Coupling medium
- Patient surface
These air pockets can interfere with acoustic transmission and reduce the amount of shock-wave energy reaching the stone.
This was a phantom laboratory study using a Dornier Delta-2 RC lithotripter.
The investigators compared conventional semi-liquid coupling gel with proprietary solid polyacrylamide gel pads measuring:
- 150 mm in diameter
- 4 mm thickness
- 8 mm thickness
An inline Optical Coupling Control system allowed trapped air within the coupling interface to be visualised and quantified.
After 200 shock waves at energy level 2, model-stone disintegration was:
- 92.3% with the 4-mm icPad
- 85.0% with the 8-mm icPad
- 45.5% with conventional semi-liquid gel
The difference was statistically significant.
The number of shock waves required for complete model-stone disintegration was also lower with the solid coupling pads:
- 242.0 ± 13.8 shocks with the 4-mm icPad
- 248.7 ± 6.3 shocks with the 8-mm icPad
- 351.0 ± 54.6 shocks with semi-liquid gel
Optical assessment confirmed substantially fewer trapped air pockets with the solid pad.
Measured air-pocket area was approximately:
- 0.38% with the 8-mm icPad
- 0.92% after simulated sliding of the 8-mm icPad
- 2.55% with conventional semi-liquid gel
The study therefore demonstrated a fundamental principle:
Reducing air within the coupling interface can substantially improve the efficiency of shock-wave transmission and stone fragmentation.
Importantly, the investigators themselves stated that further evidence was required before translating the phantom findings into routine human treatment.
Subsequent clinical observational research involving 300 patients reported higher successful stone-disintegration rates with the same solid coupling concept compared with conventional semi-liquid gel, providing later clinical support for the original phantom findings. However, that later study was observational rather than randomized.
Comments & Discussion0 comments
Discuss the publication's evidence, limitations and practical relevance. Please do not include identifiable patient information or individual medical advice.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.
Please log in to join the discussion.
