Effect of coupling fluid tonicity on pain and fragmentation outcomes in ESWL: a prospective comparative study.
Urolithiasis · 2026 · Vol. 54 · Issue 1
Academy Summary
Bayraktar and colleagues investigated whether the tonicity of the coupling fluid used during extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy (ESWL) influences treatment-related pain, stone fragmentation and superficial skin effects.
This prospective controlled clinical study included 294 adult patients with renal pelvis stones measuring 5–20 mm.
Patients were allocated to three coupling-fluid groups:
- Hypotonic degassed water: 97 patients
- Isotonic 0.9% NaCl: 99 patients
- Hypertonic 3% NaCl: 98 patients
The primary outcomes were:
- Post-ESWL pain measured using the Visual Analogue Scale (VAS)
- Study-defined fragmentation success, defined as residual fragments smaller than 4 mm on non-contrast CT performed 2–4 weeks after treatment.
Pain scores differed significantly across the three groups.
Median post-treatment VAS scores were:
- Hypotonic water: 5
- Isotonic saline: 5
- Hypertonic 3% saline: 4
The overall difference was statistically significant at p = 0.005.
However, after correction for multiple comparisons, the statistically significant difference remained only between:
Isotonic 0.9% NaCl vs. Hypertonic 3% NaCl
with a Bonferroni-corrected p = 0.004.
The difference between hypertonic saline and hypotonic degassed water did not remain statistically significant after correction.
Multivariable analysis indicated that the lower pain score associated with the hypertonic group remained significant independently of the recorded treatment energy.
Importantly, coupling-fluid tonicity did not significantly influence fragmentation success.
Study-defined fragmentation success rates were:
- Hypotonic: 56.7%
- Isotonic: 59.6%
- Hypertonic: 57.1%
The difference was not statistically significant:
p = 0.907.
Skin petechiae and/or ecchymosis decreased numerically as fluid tonicity increased, from approximately 6.2% to 1.0%, but this difference was also not statistically significant.
The study therefore introduces a novel concept:
The physical characteristics of the SWL coupling fluid may influence patient comfort even when fragmentation effectiveness remains unchanged.
Comments & Discussion0 comments
Discuss the publication's evidence, limitations and practical relevance. Please do not include identifiable patient information or individual medical advice.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.
Please log in to join the discussion.
