Courses List

0
No products in the cart.
← Literature Database

Effect of air bubbles in the coupling medium on efficacy of extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy.

Practice Point

Arun Jain, Tariq K Shah

European urology · 2007 · Vol. 51 · Issue 6 · 1680-6; discussion 1686-7

PMID: 17112655 DOI: 10.1016/j.eururo.2006.10.049

Academy Summary

Jain and Shah investigated how air bubbles trapped within the coupling medium influence the effectiveness of extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy (ESWL).

The study addressed a fundamental change in lithotripter design.

The original Dornier HM3 used a water bath, allowing shock waves to travel through a relatively continuous acoustic medium. Newer dry-head or water-cushion lithotripters introduced an additional interface between:

  • Treatment-head cushion
  • Coupling medium
  • Patient

This interface creates the possibility of trapped air and therefore loss of shock-wave transmission.

The investigators performed a standardized in-vitro experiment using 40 artificial stones treated with a STORZ Modulith SLK lithotripter.

Four coupling conditions were evaluated:

  • Conventional ultrasound gel containing visible air bubbles
  • The same conventional ultrasound gel after visible bubbles were removed
  • Thin Therasonic ultrasound gel with minimal bubbles
  • Silicone oil with minimal bubbles

The percentage of the coupling interface occupied by air bubbles was assessed, and the resulting stone damage was quantified by measuring:

  • Crater diameter
  • Crater depth
  • Crater volume

Measurements were performed by two blinded observers.

The results demonstrated a clear relationship between fewer air bubbles and greater stone disruption.

Mean crater volumes were:

  • Conventional ultrasound gel with bubbles: 49.2 ± 32.6 mm³
  • Therasonic gel: 102.4 ± 33.4 mm³
  • Silicone oil: 98.8 ± 9.8 mm³
  • Conventional ultrasound gel after visible bubbles were removed: 163.5 ± 22.6 mm³

The greatest fragmentation effect was therefore obtained not by changing to another coupling material, but by removing the visible air bubbles from conventional ultrasound gel.

Both crater depth and crater volume increased significantly as the amount of air within the coupling medium decreased.

The authors concluded that eliminating visible bubbles from conventional gel could improve experimental ESWL efficiency by as much as approximately threefold compared with poorly coupled gel.

The study also included a small clinical comparison involving 10 patients treated with both ultrasound gels.

Interestingly, the thinner Therasonic gel produced significantly greater treatment-related pain than conventional ultrasound gel:

  • Conventional gel median pain score: 3.5
  • Therasonic gel median pain score: 8.0
  • p < 0.001

This finding suggests that improving acoustic transmission can also increase the amount of shock-wave energy experienced by superficial tissues.

The study therefore reinforces a central principle of modern SWL:

The energy selected on the lithotripter is not necessarily the energy transmitted into the patient or delivered to the stone.

Current EAU guidance specifically cites this study and gives a strong recommendation to ensure correct use of the coupling agent because effective shock-wave transmission depends on it.

Unlock the Academy Interpretation for Free

Create a free Lithotripsy Academy account or log in to access the complete Academy interpretation, including Key Findings, Clinical Takeaway, Limitations, and Expert Commentary

Subscribe to View Details Already a member? Log in
Comments & Discussion0 comments

Discuss the publication's evidence, limitations and practical relevance. Please do not include identifiable patient information or individual medical advice.

No comments yet. Start the discussion.