Monitoring the coupling of the lithotripter therapy head with skin during routine shock wave lithotripsy with a surveillance camera.
The Journal of urology · 2012 · Vol. 187 · Issue 1 · 157-63
Academy Summary
Bohris and colleagues investigated the quality of acoustic coupling during routine clinical shock wave lithotripsy (SWL) and examined how air within the coupling interface affects stone fragmentation efficiency.
The study addressed an important practical problem with modern dry-head lithotripters.
Shock waves must travel from the treatment head through:
- Water-filled therapy cushion
- Coupling gel
- Patient's skin
- Soft tissue
- Stone
Air trapped between the treatment head and the patient's skin can significantly interfere with this acoustic pathway.
The investigators integrated a video surveillance camera into a Dornier DoLi SII lithotripter, allowing continuous visualization of the coupling interface during 30 routine SWL treatments.
Importantly, the treating urologist was blinded to the camera image, reproducing normal clinical practice in which the coupling interface is usually invisible to the operator.
The clinical component included:
- 30 SWL treatment sessions
- 26 patients
- 21 men
- 5 women
- Mean BMI approximately 27.2 kg/m²
- 26 renal stone treatments
- 4 ureteral stone treatments
Four urologists performed the treatments.
Stone localisation was performed using:
- X-ray in 20 treatments
- Isocentric ultrasound in 10 treatments
Three different coupling gels were evaluated:
- LithoClear
- Sonogel
- A custom-made low-viscosity gel
Good coupling, defined as less than 5% air within the relevant coupling area, was achieved in only:
10 of 30 treatments
In contrast:
- 20 of 30 treatments had more than 5% air
- 8 treatments had more than 20% air
The low-viscosity gel produced the best coupling conditions.
The investigators then tested the effect of different amounts of air on fragmentation using model stones.
The mean number of shock waves required for complete fragmentation was:
- 0% air: 100 ± 4 shocks
- 5% air: 126 ± 3 shocks
- 10% air: 151 ± 8 shocks
- 20% air: 287 ± 5 shocks
Therefore, when approximately 20% of the coupling area contained air, almost three times as many shock waves were required to achieve the same model-stone fragmentation.
The study demonstrated that poor coupling is not an occasional theoretical problem.
It occurs commonly during routine SWL and can substantially reduce the efficiency of energy transmission.
Current EAU guidance reflects this principle and states that proper acoustic coupling is important for SWL outcome, with a strong recommendation to ensure correct use of the coupling agent because it is crucial for effective shock-wave transmission.
Comments & Discussion0 comments
Discuss the publication's evidence, limitations and practical relevance. Please do not include identifiable patient information or individual medical advice.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.
Please log in to join the discussion.
