The efficacy of a range of contact media as coupling agents in extracorporeal shockwave lithotripsy.
BJU international · 2001 · Vol. 88 · Issue 4 · 321-4
Academy Summary
Cartledge and colleagues investigated whether the type of coupling medium used during shock wave lithotripsy (SWL) influences stone fragmentation efficiency.
With dry-head or water-free lithotripters, a coupling medium is required between the treatment head and the patient to transmit acoustic energy efficiently.
Although coupling gels were often treated simply as passive contact materials, the investigators questioned whether different media might transmit shock waves differently and therefore alter fragmentation performance.
The study used an electromagnetic Dornier Compact lithotripter.
A specially designed jig held 10-mm phantom stones at the focal point of the lithotripter.
Five different coupling agents were compared:
- Petroleum jelly
- Ultrasonography jelly
- EMLA cream
- Instillagel
- Commercial water-soluble lubricating jelly
For each coupling medium, the investigators measured the number of shock waves required to fragment the phantom stone.
The type of coupling agent significantly affected fragmentation.
Petroleum jelly required significantly more shock waves to fragment stones than all the other tested coupling agents.
In contrast:
- Instillagel
- Water-soluble lubricating jelly
required significantly fewer shock waves than the other agents tested.
Despite the particularly efficient fragmentation observed with Instillagel and lubricating jelly, the authors concluded that ultrasound gel was probably the most appropriate practical coupling medium for routine lithotripsy.
The central message was therefore:
The coupling agent is not acoustically inert.
Its physical properties can influence how effectively shock-wave energy is transmitted and consequently how efficiently a stone fragments.
This concept remains relevant in contemporary SWL. Current EAU guidance states that proper acoustic coupling is important and specifically notes that ultrasound gel is probably the most widely used lithotripsy coupling agent. The guideline strongly recommends correct use of the coupling agent because it is crucial for effective shock-wave transmission.
Comments & Discussion0 comments
Discuss the publication's evidence, limitations and practical relevance. Please do not include identifiable patient information or individual medical advice.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.
Please log in to join the discussion.
